Skip to main content

Does School Kill Creativity

 Ken Robinson TED Talk
These are my notes from a TED Talk by Sir Ken Robinson: Do Schools Kill Creativity. I thought the ideas were great, and very well delivered. I agreed with most of the things he said; how schools force students to stay still and not make mistakes. He brought up a very good argument; children are not afraid of being wrong. It's not that big of a deal. But as children grow up, they start learning that being wrong is somehow stupid, and makes you seem uninterested or uneducated. When in fact, the child just makes a mistake, just did something wrong. I really liked that he brought that up because that's how most teachers operate their class. If you're wrong, don't speak! So children learn not to speak.

He also said the future is unpredictable, we don't know how our current technology will shape our future. And yet we are still using the outdated ways of teaching we used to in around the 19th century. Subjects like math and science are considered valued if you are good in those subjects it means you will find a job that will help you stay financially stable. Yay. But if you are good at art or music or dance, people will say the age-old argument: "How do you expect to make money off of ____." Anything creative gone in kids because they are taught, from a very young age, that math and science are the "smarter" subjects. This is because, as Ken Robinson said, when school systems in the 19th century started to kick off, they wanted to produce factory workers. People that will keep the economy running. And that may have been the right path for back then, but today we need more creative people to find creative solutions!

Imagine if Shakespeare was told to be quiet and sit still. (I think I drew a pretty good representation of that in my notes.) Imagine if people told him "You'll never make money off of stories! Who's gonna remember Romeo and Juliet? And talk normally!!!" We would never have all these amazing stories! In the same sense, somewhere sitting in a classroom, a future best-selling writer, or dancer, or artist, or basically anyone creative. And I bet you anything that those kids are considered "the troublemakers" in their class because they aren't interested in math or science. Instead, they'd rather be creative. Ugh! Maybe some will get the creativeness beaten out of them, but others will learn to ignore all those opposing voices and make the world a better place.

Comments

  1. You pull out a lot of parts of the TED talk that resonated with me as well! I have seen this talk about five times now but when you specifically pointed out that kids have no problem being wrong until they are TAUGHT that being wrong is wrong and not okay, that really stood out to me. This has no space for falling forward or learning from mistakes and this way of teaching (which everyone has experienced at least once) is what eliminates creativity. You are on such a good path right now and I can't wait to read more of your posts!
    -Anna

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Sourdough Bread Journey

 I've always been interested in baking bread and I recently took on the endeavour of baking sourdough. Immediately, I started to hear how difficult sourdough bread is to bake due to the the time consuming aspect of baking the bread properly. Even before this journey, I knew that bread-bakers always attributed sourdough to a very difficult bread. So, I started this journey with my guard up, expecting to make many mistakes that would result in uneatable bread.  Guess what. They lied.  I'm not saying it was incredibly easy, there are plenty of lessons I've learned through my mistakes. But those mistakes do not mark a difficulty for me, they mark my accomplishments. I've made mistakes I never thought I could make through my journey of baking sourdough, but they taught me valuable lessons and I don't regret a single mistake I made.  I decided to dust off my blog after taking to a friend about sourdough, and all she had heard about it was that it was the most difficult th...

Students telling their stories

I think the greatest way teachers can help students is by letting them tell their story and paying attention to it. This can be by a short story assignment or just encouraging kids to write. Especially for kids who are bullied--we have a lot on our minds that often goes unsaid because we felt like no one would care. It's important to encourage students to write about their experiences so that they could try to learn from them. A great resource I found, though it seems a little rushed, is National Novel Writing Month or NaNoWriMo. This website encourages people, student or not, to write a "novel" in the month of November and submit it at the end of the month. What you do is you make a profile so that you can start your novel on November 1st. And every time you write, you copy and paste your progress into their website so they can keep track of your progress. You earn badges along the way and even get some feedback from other users. This is a great way to encourage kid...

Talking About Tragedies at School

The other day in my Literacy of the Learner class, the teachers asked us if discussing tragedies in class would be appropriate. Should we talk about personal tragedies like loved ones passing away, or national tragedies like school shootings, or both? My opinion is that we should talk about tragedies in schools because as soon as kids get out of school they will be exposed to this topic anyway. There is no point shielding kids from troubling news because they do have a life outside of school, and opinions you don't get to hear in classrooms. School is supposed to make students ready for "real life", and in "real life" we are free to discuss controversial topics and give our own opinion. Personally, I'm still not used to the freedom in I have in CSU. I can share my opinion without a teacher pulling me aside and asking me not to do that? I can discuss a controversial topic in a polite manner? What?! If I had been exposed to this type of behavior earlier, I...