Skip to main content

Does School Kill Creativity

 Ken Robinson TED Talk
These are my notes from a TED Talk by Sir Ken Robinson: Do Schools Kill Creativity. I thought the ideas were great, and very well delivered. I agreed with most of the things he said; how schools force students to stay still and not make mistakes. He brought up a very good argument; children are not afraid of being wrong. It's not that big of a deal. But as children grow up, they start learning that being wrong is somehow stupid, and makes you seem uninterested or uneducated. When in fact, the child just makes a mistake, just did something wrong. I really liked that he brought that up because that's how most teachers operate their class. If you're wrong, don't speak! So children learn not to speak.

He also said the future is unpredictable, we don't know how our current technology will shape our future. And yet we are still using the outdated ways of teaching we used to in around the 19th century. Subjects like math and science are considered valued if you are good in those subjects it means you will find a job that will help you stay financially stable. Yay. But if you are good at art or music or dance, people will say the age-old argument: "How do you expect to make money off of ____." Anything creative gone in kids because they are taught, from a very young age, that math and science are the "smarter" subjects. This is because, as Ken Robinson said, when school systems in the 19th century started to kick off, they wanted to produce factory workers. People that will keep the economy running. And that may have been the right path for back then, but today we need more creative people to find creative solutions!

Imagine if Shakespeare was told to be quiet and sit still. (I think I drew a pretty good representation of that in my notes.) Imagine if people told him "You'll never make money off of stories! Who's gonna remember Romeo and Juliet? And talk normally!!!" We would never have all these amazing stories! In the same sense, somewhere sitting in a classroom, a future best-selling writer, or dancer, or artist, or basically anyone creative. And I bet you anything that those kids are considered "the troublemakers" in their class because they aren't interested in math or science. Instead, they'd rather be creative. Ugh! Maybe some will get the creativeness beaten out of them, but others will learn to ignore all those opposing voices and make the world a better place.

Comments

  1. You pull out a lot of parts of the TED talk that resonated with me as well! I have seen this talk about five times now but when you specifically pointed out that kids have no problem being wrong until they are TAUGHT that being wrong is wrong and not okay, that really stood out to me. This has no space for falling forward or learning from mistakes and this way of teaching (which everyone has experienced at least once) is what eliminates creativity. You are on such a good path right now and I can't wait to read more of your posts!
    -Anna

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Research Journal #2: Why My Project Is Important

I'm getting better at interviewing people. I went to the library and the park to interview people yesterday and to Olde Town today. Each location gave me a different experience. When I was at the library people were brief, and didn't really want to talk to me because they were reading or working. I was only able to interview three people there before running out. The park was fun. I interviewed some kids, which was a really fun experience. The kids were very honest about what they were seeing around them and were more opinionated than I expected them to be. Olde town was probably the worst place I could have chosen to interview people. I only talked to two people there, because everyone else was either scared of me or didn't want to talk to me. I think I will spend some time writing down their transcripts and work on my people skills.  I found an article that might help with my situation. " How to Conduct an Effective Job Interview " is a guide for employers to

What Is The Use Of Poetry

I have never been good at poetry. Never. I can appreciate poetry because it's something deep and layered and has hidden meanings in it, but I can never write it. I guess I gave up trying after a few times. But then I went to Get Lit and I have to say, it was really great! To see so many poets sharing their poetry and in a way sharing a part of themselves was so inspiring to see! I got to see my friends share their poetry, I got to see the people listening to the poetry respond to it in a way that was inclusive and accepting. The whole environment of Get Lit was so great, I want to experience that again. That being said, I think poetry exists to let readers see a tiny part of a story. May that story be a person or an event. Poems have layers in them in which you get to make up your own rules. I love Emily Dickenson's poetry because of that--she doesn't conform to any rules, she makes her own rules! This shows the rebellious side of Dickenson that I have fallen in love with

Research Journal #4: Getting to The End Product

I think I have improved my project a lot, but it still feels like I should be doing more. I always feel this way when I'm turning in an assignment. Probably because I should  be doing something more. I just can't figure out what that is though, so I guess that means I'm finished. The final product looks a lot better than the rough draft so I guess that's also a good sign. I got great feedback, which helped a lot. The feedback was honest and truthful, but it wasn't rude which is something I'm not used to. I remember getting my essays edited in high school, and they would come back covered in red pen with stuff I should be improving. I remember one time, my paper was so bad that the girl had to get a blank piece of paper to make suggestions. This time though, the suggested edits were awesome suggestions, and they really helped improve my UGP.